Welcome to American Seniors First Choice

Quality Protection For Your Needs

Customizing your insurance is simple with American Seniors First Choice. That’s because our specialized agents are experts at creating bundle choices for your specific needs. Located in the growing city of Bowling Green, Kentucky, we have been providing insurance services for the residents of Kentucky and surrounding states since 1996. We specialize in Medicare Supplements and Life Benefit. Sign up today and receive protection from one of the best in the industry.



Come visit our new location

on 31W Bypass 

A Bit About Us

American Seniors First Choice offers clients the best possible protection for all of their insurance needs. As one of the leading insurance companies in Southern Kentucky, we have built quite the clientele by maintaining a strict customer-comes-first approach. If you are looking to do business with a top notch company that does everything in its power to ensure your satisfaction, contact us today. Our experts are here for your every insurance need and will be happy to supply you with a free quote.


Davy Myatt


Brandi 2021_edited.jpg

Brandi Fuller

Agency Manager


What We Do

We Provide Solutions

Senior couple hugging
Happy Family with Pets
Family Fun

Medicare Supplement

The Protection You Need

To avoid unnecessary worry about what the future holds, we ensure that you are covered. With established relationships with numerous carriers, let us put together the optimal Medicare Supplement Insurance Package that offers the highest level of protection for you. Contact us to make an appointment with one of our experienced consultants and receive a free quote. We’re here to supply you with the insurance you really need.

Life Insurance

Not Just for Seniors

American Seniors First Choice has been helping people feel safer since 1996, providing our clients with the best Insurance Packages in the industry. Are you spending too much precious time thinking about what might happen to you in the future? Don’t worry! We’re here to put together a policy that best meets your specific needs.

First Diagnosis Cancer and Heart Attack Coverage

Ready for Anything

Everyone wants to live a happy, healthy life. But cancer, a heart attack or stroke can happen at any time. Having a heart attack or stroke or being diagnosed with cancer can quickly cause financial problems. That’s why it pays to plan ahead.


Get In Touch

NOTE: Due to Covid-19, as of 02/01/2021, we will not be available for 
walk-ins. Please call or email us to schedule an appointment. 

661 US 31W Bypass 
Bowling Green, KY 42102

Local (270) 746-0575

Toll Free (800) 500-0375

Thanks for submitting!

Image by Aaron Burden